In the landscape of independent school management, the decision to transition from annual re-enrollment to continuous enrollment represents a pivotal shift with wide-ranging implications. Oak Hall School’s journey serves as a beacon of inspiration, illuminating the challenges associated with the traditional model and the transformative benefits of embracing continuity in enrollment practices.

Established in 1970, Oak Hall School in Gainesville, FL serves over 800 students in grades PK-12. The school’s mission: A welcoming, diverse, and supportive learning community empowering students to pursue their academic, artistic, and athletic passions.


  • Cultural Shift: Yearly re-enrollment perpetuates a culture of uncertainty, compelling families to reassess their enrollment decisions annually. This perpetual cycle of reconsideration undermines the institution’s long-term identity and fosters a perception of the school as a transactional entity rather than a nurturing community. Addressing this challenge requires a fundamental cultural shift towards continuity and commitment.
  • Human Capital Drain: The cyclical nature of yearly re-enrollment imposes a significant strain on enrollment management teams, diverting their focus and energy towards repetitive administrative tasks. This inefficiency hampers productivity and detracts from the team’s capacity to engage in strategic initiatives aimed at recruitment, transition, and retention. Overcoming this challenge necessitates reimagining enrollment management processes to optimize team resources and drive impactful outcomes.
  • Disrupted Strategic Planning: Annual re-enrollment disrupts the school’s ability to engage in proactive strategic planning, prolonging decision-making processes and introducing unnecessary complexity. By tethering enrollment-related decisions to annual cycles, schools risk diverting attention away from critical matters such as hiring, curriculum development, and resource allocation. Addressing this challenge demands a holistic approach to enrollment management that aligns with broader strategic objectives and promotes long-term sustainability.

Benefits and Transition Strategies

  • Establishing Clear Expectations: Transitioning to continuous enrollment provides families and the community with clarity and predictability, fostering trust and stability. By establishing clear expectations regarding enrollment processes and timelines, schools can cultivate a culture of transparency and accountability, laying the foundation for sustained growth and success.
  • Leveraging Team Creativity: Continuous enrollment liberates enrollment management teams from the constraints of contract chasing, empowering them to focus their efforts on creative recruitment and retention strategies. By harnessing the collective creativity and expertise of the team, schools can develop innovative initiatives tailored to effectively attract and retain students. Oak Hall School’s success in this regard is exemplified by its strategic implementation of Saturday tours, shadow days, and college prep workshops, all designed to enhance engagement and enrollment.
  • Cultivating a Retention Culture: Continuous enrollment cultivates a culture of retention by shifting the narrative from yearly renewals to long-term commitment. By prioritizing the retention of current students, schools can nurture a sense of belonging and loyalty within the community, fostering enduring relationships that extend beyond mere contractual obligations. This emphasis on retention enhances the overall student experience and contributes to the school’s long-term stability and success.

Transition Strategies

  • Secure Buy-In: Achieving a successful transition requires buy-in from the entire school community, from leadership to faculty, staff, and families. By integrating continuous enrollment into the school’s strategic plan, leaders can demonstrate a commitment to fostering a culture of continuity and excellence.
  • Effective Communication: Transparent and comprehensive communication is paramount in facilitating a seamless transition to continuous enrollment. Schools must employ a multi-faceted approach to communication, utilizing various channels such as emails, in-person meetings, and written correspondence to convey the rationale, timelines, and expectations associated with the transition.
  • Collaborative Approach: Transitioning to continuous enrollment requires collaboration across various stakeholders, including legal counsel, financial officers, enrollment management teams, and faculty. By fostering collaboration and leveraging the expertise of diverse perspectives, schools can ensure alignment with legal requirements, financial considerations, and strategic objectives.
  • Consistency is Key: Consistency is essential in implementing continuous enrollment effectively. Schools must maintain consistency in timelines, processes, and communication to instill confidence and trust within the school community. By adhering to established protocols and maintaining transparency, schools can maximize the benefits of continuous enrollment while minimizing disruptions.

Oak Hall School’s remarkable journey is a testament to the transformative power of continuous enrollment. With retention rates soaring from the low 80s to the high 90s and an impressive 35% enrollment growth, the benefits of embracing continuity in enrollment practices are undeniable. Schools can chart a course towards sustained growth, success, and community engagement by overcoming the challenges associated with traditional re-enrollment models and embracing a culture of commitment and excellence.

  • Admissions/Financial Aid
  • Marketing/Communications
Nancy Coleman, Director of Enrollment Management, Oak Hall School
Nancy Coleman joined Oak Hall as a first grade teacher in 1997 with a B.Ed. in education from Converse University. She became the lower school director of admissions in 2005, and in 2015 became the director of enrollment management for preschool–grade 12.
Jaime Gresley, Director of Advancement, Oak Hall School
Jaime Gresley joined Oak Hall in 2020 as the director of advancement. She has a B.A. in political science from Northern Arizona University and an M. Ed in college student personnel from Bowling Green State University. Prior to joining Oak Hall School, she spent more than a decade at the University of Florida and Arizona State University, working to advance the student and family experience.